Booking Agency or DIY? Pros and Pitfalls for Self-Booking Musicians

For many musicians, booking is one of the most important – and sometimes most frustrating – aspects of their career. Should you handle it all yourself, or team up with a booking agency? Both paths come with pros and cons, and the right choice depends on where you are in your journey, what your goals are, and how much time and energy you can invest.

DIY Booking: Freedom and Full Responsibility

Booking yourself means total control. You decide where you want to play, when, and who to contact. It’s a great approach for emerging or independent artists who want to build their own network and gain first-hand experience with how the industry works.

But DIY booking takes time, patience, and a lot of persistence. You’re responsible for writing emails, following up, negotiating fees, handling contracts, and managing logistics. Getting through to bookers and venues – many of whom are already flooded with requests – can be tough and often discouraging.

Booking Agencies: Connections and Professional Support

A good booking agency brings experience, industry knowledge, and connections. They know who to reach out to, how to pitch you, and how to keep your calendar filled with gigs that match your level and ambitions. For many musicians, this allows them to focus more on the creative side and less on admin.

The downside? Most agencies won’t take you on unless you’re already somewhat established or in demand. They also take a cut of your earnings, and you’ll need to give up some control over where and how you perform. Agencies also tend to prioritize what’s financially sustainable – not just your artistic vision.

When Does Each Approach Work Best?

DIY makes sense if you:

Are just starting out and want to learn the ropes
Have time and motivation to network and follow up
Play mostly local gigs or niche venues where personal outreach matters
Are organized and comfortable selling yourself

A booking agency is valuable if you:

Have a growing reputation and demand
Are performing regionally, nationally, or internationally
Need help managing logistics and negotiations
Want to spend more time on music and less on administration

It Doesn’t Have to Be Either/Or

Many artists begin by booking themselves and later partner with an agency. Some use an agency for big or international gigs while continuing to handle smaller shows on their own. The key is to find a setup that aligns with your goals, your genre, and your available resources – and to be honest about what you’re best at and what you’d rather hand off.

At the end of the day, booking is about relationships, timing, and persistence – whether you do it yourself or with professional help.

‍